Percolator vs Drip: Which One Makes the Best Cup of Joe?

There seems to be a never-ending percolator vs drip debate. Which makes the best coffee? 

You’d be surprised to learn that both tools are actually similar in the sense that they have bottom chambers that heat up water. The steam produced then rises, condensates, and drips through the coffee grounds located in the upper chamber. 

While the brewing cycle is similar, there are distinct differences between the two. We’re here to outline what makes these devices different and help settle the score. 

The Innovative Percolator 

The percolator was invented in 1865 by American soldier Count Rumford. In 1889, it was designed for stovetop use by farmer Hanson Goodrich. 

Today, you can find electric or stovetop models. These devices have been a staple way before the drip coffee machines were invented. They produce strong java by cycling water through coffee grounds several times, whereas drip machines only run water once. In turn, users receive very strong (sometimes over-extracted) java. 

The Modern Drip Coffee Maker

When drip machines came around in the 1970s, many people replaced their percolators with them. Why? Well, they offer an inexpensive way to make coffee fast with minimal effort (there’s truly little to no learning curving). To brew java using a drip machine, you simply place a paper filter and your favorite coffee grounds into the designated compartment. Add some water to the reservoir and hit brew. 

Which is Easier to Use?

Both machines heat up water which then causes steam to rise up until it reaches the drip area. Coffee is then dispersed into your cup. The main difference between the two is that drip machines only cycle the water one time, whereas percolators cycle water through the coffee multiple times, which often leads to over-extracted and bitter java.

Percolators require constant attention for this reason. To avoid burning your brew, users need to ensure water is kept at the right temperature. Using this device does require a learning curve, but once nailed down, you can expect a decent cup of joe every time. 

All in all, drip machines are easier to use.

Which Produces Better Coffee?

So, let’s settle the debate: drip coffee vs percolator java. It’s not that simple (sigh). When deciding which produces the better batch of coffee, a few things need to be considered.

Brew Strength 

Consider a percolator if you like strong coffee and don’t mind working a little extra to get it. They brew stronger java because they are cycling the water through the coffee several times. If you prefer cleaner, less strong coffee, go with a drip coffee machine since these only run water through once. 

Remember that percolator coffee will be bolder; however, it will likely be over-extracted, meaning you won’t get many complex flavors. Drip machines will offer more depth and offer a lighter mouthfeel.

Brew Size

Drip machines come in handy if you are making coffee for 2-4 people. Now, if you have a lot of people waiting on coffee and not too much time, a percolator is the better choice. Some are able to brew twelve cups at a time. This is great if your coffee drinkers are in it for the caffeine and not so much for the flavor. Plus, they can always add some sugar or cream to their liking.

Convenience 

A large advantage of drip machines over percolators is the convenience factor. Drip machines are fast. They take care of brew time and water temperature. However, percolators are more economical. If you’re on a tight budget, percolators are a great choice since they won’t break the bank. You’ll have the option to choose between a stovetop or an electric model (electric being easier to use).

The Verdict 

Is percolated coffee better than drip? Personally, while it’s all a matter of personal preference, we’d go with the drip java if we had to choose. While it doesn’t have as much strength as percolators, they do produce cleaner brews.

If you’re looking for ease of use and complex flavors, go with a drip coffee machine. Now, if you’re looking for a stronger brew or machine you can make big batches with, a percolator is for you. Both options are affordable and come in different sizes, colors, and designs.

Happy caffeinating!